Monday, January 14, 2013

Laws Alone Won’t Stop Rapes





For the past month, Indian rape victim’s horror story has probably been followed all around the world. While some in western world must be thinking why so much attention to just one rape, others who are probably more aware of the women’s plight in India will know why Indian protestors and world media should be applauded for bringing this case up.


My thoughts changed a few times in since the news broke of this rape. Initially, I was thinking she must be a daughter of an influential man otherwise no way a rape victim can get such attention in India. India media rarely focuses so heavily on something unless it is linked to elite class. Some quick facts checking and speaking to few people back in India, the story shook my mind like no rape story has ever done.

This was no ordinary rape. Close to 2 rapes happen every day in Delhi. Even this stat should be much higher as more often than not, rape victims don’t report it fearing further harassment and shame. Reporters who got hold of some info from doctors who were treating the girl were shocked. The brutality these rapists showed is probably unheard of even in India. No newspaper can publish the details of such brutal, animalistic and inhumane treatment of the victim. Blood must have boiled or else this rape would have been treated just like others. I couldn’t sleep, I realised later I am not the only one and thus the protests.

I get asked by friends in Australia about situation back home. More than the rape, it’s the sexual harassment & molestation which a woman faces and fights almost on daily basis in Delhi. My wife who is from Delhi has convinced me long time ago that Delhi may be the worse place for women to live. I probably concur but I have lived in some other parts of India as well to know the problem is deep-rooted in India. The amount of ogling, eve teasing and leering a woman faces in India is staggering. There are not many women living in Delhi who hasn’t been harassed, faced lewd comments or even molestation. I don’t know any.

To understand this attitude of some Indian males, one will have to understand Indian culture first. While Indian culture westerners know of is very traditional and diverse, not many know of some of the deep-rooted misogyny and the underlying sexist religious practises which have been passed on by generations after generations to next one. While situation has improved somewhat I cities, in most villages in India, women are still treated as 2nd class citizens in the name of culture and traditional values. The society still hasn’t matured enough to look back at some of the cultural & traditional practises and questions them. There are not many people in India who will let their daughter/wife/mother go to a police station alone to file any kind of complaint or grievances. Indian Police themselves face accusations of sexism within it ranks.

Sadly, now the society will ask women to dress modestly and stop going outside after dark. Somehow it is a women’s fault as always. Already few local leaders in Haryana state are asking government to not implement death penalties for rape. These very same leaders have recommended reducing the minimum age requirements for marriages. You see, rape happens because women when not dressed appropriately are asking for it or have too much freedom when instead they should be married and doing household chores. Even the protesters are called “Dented & Painted” women by a high profile politician who happens to be the son of Indian president as well.

Indian columnist Karan Thapar probably summed it best in an article in Hindustan Times, a prominent Delhi newspaper: “Rape happens because Indian men don’t respect women and treat them as play-things. And let’s face it, this is a direct result of the way we bring up our men and the way we encourage them to think of women.The problem begins with parenting. We treat boys like little Gods and daughters as a curse. And when I say we, I really mean mothers who spoil their sons whilst disregarding their daughters. Attitudes inculcated in childhood lead to adolescents, young men and, finally, adults treating women with disrespect and even violence. So the fault begins at home. It begins with our mums and dads. In fact, hurtful as it may sound, it begins with mum.”’

I quite agree. I sincerely hope that Indian government realise that this problem is far too deeply engraved in society to be solved by making few new laws. The problem beings at homes, it begins at school, it begins at our religious beliefs, and it begins in our cultural values. It is almost at every layer of our society. Upper class, middle class, villages: it’s everywhere. A national inquiry/ commission with wide ranging power needs to be created to understand the causes behind Indian males attitude towards women and its recommendations needs to be implemented. It needs to be solved by creating awareness. It needs to be solved by religious heads. This is a nation-wide problem about which sadly no serious effort has ever been made to understand “why?”. New laws like castration of organs of those who rape wouldn’t solve the issue. It’s far too complex a problem and sadly, there’s no quick-fix.

1 comment: